One year after their father's death, Charlie and Betty continue to ignore their grief, each other, and the mysterious creature following them. Their estranged Uncle Pete, believed to be dead, claims to know how to end the suffering.

Emily Young, a senior, hopes to be elected as her sorority's president. She decides to adopt a lovable sloth, believing it will be a great mascot and boost her chances of winning. However, things take a dark turn when a series of murders occur and the sloth becomes the main suspect.

On an evening drive, Ellington bumps into an old fling. As things tend to go whenever he is around, Ellington's night takes a turn for the worse.