In Love Never Dies, the Phantom has escaped from Paris to New York's Coney Island. He has finally found a place to hide and create his opera set in the fairground, The Phantom's Phantasma. He lures Christine Daaé, his former protégé and love interest, to perform in his new production. However, Christine is now married to Raoul, and they have a ten-year-old son named Gustave. As the story unfolds, secrets are revealed, and the characters are faced with choices that will change their lives forever.

A story of obsession, romance, and tragedy unfolds in the opera house of Royal Albert Hall. The Phantom, an architect turned musical genius, becomes infatuated with a young soprano and will stop at nothing to make her the star of the show. As dark secrets and hidden desires come to light, the lives of the characters intertwine in a web of love, betrayal, and murder.