Twelve-year-old Cole Johnson is bullied by his neighbor Jeremy, but his babysitter Bee stands up for him and scares Jeremy off. The following day, when his parents go out for an overnight stay at a hotel, Bee and Cole spend quality time together until he has to go to bed. Cole discovers that his hot babysitter belongs to a satanic cult that will stop at nothing to keep him quiet. He tries to escape, but the cult members chase him down, leading to a final showdown.

In this horror-comedy sequel, Cole Johnson, now a high school student, is still traumatized by his previous encounter with a satanic cult and has trouble believing that they are truly gone. When they resurface to continue their demonic rituals, Cole must once again face his fears and protect himself and his friends from their evil plans.