Emily's manipulative boyfriend steals her apartment and her parents unexpectedly leave her responsible for meeting the holiday decorating HOA requirements. She is harassed by the current HOA president and persuaded to take over a time-consuming parade plan. Despite the challenges, she decides to stay and make the best of the situation. In the end, she falls for the HOA jerk in a typical Hallmark movie fashion.

As the holidays approach, Emily and Jared are excited to celebrate together. Emily, embracing Evergreen Lane's festive spirit, works with Jared and neighbors to make the best Christmas yet. Being the HOA president's girlfriend doesn't stop decorating citations. When a house on the block goes up for sale, it stirs up the residents. The soon-to-be neighbors turn out to be holiday royalty, intensifying the competition. As the welcoming committee prepares, this Christmas, Evergreen Lane will shine.